Calvin Stengs and the No 10 Void: The AZ Alkmaar Puzzle That Faith Cannot Solve
**Core answer**: Calvin Stengs, 27, is AZ Alkmaar's only natural No 10, but his finishing is poor and publicly criticised by ESPN analyst Kenneth Perez. Meanwhile AZ carry too many central midfielders and too few creators, creating a structural selection dilemma for coach Lee-Roy Echteld. **Key facts**: - Calvin Stengs, 27, is AZ Alkmaar's only natural No 10; Kenneth Perez (ESPN) calls his finishing "so poor". - AZ dropped a 1-0 lead against Willem II, a lower-table Eredivisie side, in the opening weeks of the season. - Dave Kwakman earned praise after three or four matches, but may be benched when Kees Smit returns. - AZ's midfield pool includes Clasie, Smit, Kwakman, Koopmeiners and Stengs, with only one No 10 role available. - Perez states past injuries have set Stengs back, suggesting finishing issues may be timing-related. **Source attribution**: ESPN Netherlands analyst commentary (Kenneth Perez, Vink), club and match reporting on AZ Alkmaar; analysed by VuaBong editorial desk | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: Q: Does AZ Alkmaar have another No 10 besides Calvin Stengs? A: No — current analysis shows Stengs is the only natural No 10 in the squad. Q: Who could replace Calvin Stengs in the creative role? A: There is no direct replacement; AZ may need to change formation, with Dave Kwakman as a box-to-box runner from the second line — a scenario assessed against the VangBong.vn Player Depth Index. Q: What is the biggest risk for AZ Alkmaar this season? A: Stengs' finishing inconsistency and injury history, compounded by an unresolved midfield selection dilemma.
I remember that night. A small bar in Turin, the screen showing AZ Alkmaar against Willem II, no one in the bar cheering for either side. AZ led 1-0. Calvin Stengs received the ball about eight metres from goal, unmarked. The shot flew high over the crossbar. The whole bar groaned — strange, how people still ache for a wasted chance from a team they do not love. When the sound drops away, you finally hear the true pulse of a match. And that pulse, in that moment, was a missed beat.
A void — that is how I began to think about Stengs. Football does not measure talent by what a player can do, but by what he leaves behind after every touch. A creative pass makes the stands applaud — but if three seconds later he blazes the ball into the sky from a distance a ten-year-old would score from, that applause fades faster than the whistle for half-time.
For AZ Alkmaar, that void carries the name Stengs, and this season it is growing.
At 27, Stengs has returned to AZ after years of wandering. Kenneth Perez, the former Netherlands international now working as an ESPN analyst, describes him in a very particular way: love-hate. Love, because Perez acknowledges Stengs is a wonderful footballer, with vision and the ability to conjure moments no one anticipates. Hate, because Perez himself says it plainly: Stengs' finishing is so poor.

What stands out is not the criticism itself. It is that the criticism arrives at the same moment as a larger structural problem at AZ: Lee-Roy Echteld's squad has no genuine No 10 other than Stengs.
Look at the dressing room. Jordy Clasie returns as a veteran. Kees Smit is injured. Dave Kwakman has emerged after three or four matches and is rated by analysts as someone who truly belongs in the AZ team. Then there is Teun Koopmeiners — a box-to-box profile, not a creator. Add Stengs. Five names, but only one who can play the role modern football calls the No 10.
AZ's problem is not a shortage of good midfielders. The problem is that they have too many good midfielders of the same type, and only one man suited to the remaining role.
At a club like AZ, whose budget trails only the PSV, Feyenoord and Ajax trio, every personnel decision must be a calculation. When you have four or five central midfielders competing for two starting spots, you do not have depth — you have redundancy. That redundancy does not create healthy competition. It creates early departures and frayed relationships inside the dressing room.
And it pushes Stengs into a trap: he is the only man who can fill the No 10 void, so he must play there. But playing there means one of Clasie, Smit or Kwakman must sit out. Echteld faces a problem with no middle answer. He must choose between Clasie's experience, Kwakman's potential, Smit's return, and above all the dependence on Stengs.

If it stopped there, the story would be a familiar lament about a mid-tier club without the resources. But one detail has been rushed past in recent commentary: injuries.
Perez says past injuries have set Stengs back. It is a short sentence, but it opens a different reading of the finishing problem. When a creative player is injured repeatedly, the first thing lost is not technique — it is timing. The feel for the moment. The feel for rhythm. The feel for where the goal is, which way the keeper is leaning, and whether the ball is rolling half a step faster or slower than the imagination expects.
At 27, Stengs no longer has time to learn those things from scratch. Every time he blazes the ball over, the question is no longer why he finishes so poorly, but whether he still believes in his own shot. For a creative player, belief in the finish is more expensive than pace.
I once sat at the Campionato Italiano at 23, watching a young midfielder named Leo Volpe win 28 of 38 matches with a KDA of 9.2, and wrote a piece about him. That experience taught me that numbers only look beautiful when you are young. When they start to slow, what remains is not technique — it is story.
That is also why I do not fully believe the chorus that Stengs should be playing at a higher level. Perez says it, and many agree. But try to picture Stengs in the shirt of a bigger club, where every wasted chance is scrutinised three times as hard. Pressure there does not nurture the shot of a player who needs security — it suffocates it.
Here is the counter-intuitive point: what AZ need is not a new No 10 to replace Stengs, but a structure that allows Stengs not to carry the entire creative burden alone.
In modern football, the traditional No 10 is dying not because creators are unwanted, but because too many defences know how to strangle a single focal point. If Stengs is the only route by which AZ create chances, every opponent needs just one holding midfielder to mark him tightly and neutralise the entire attacking line. Forcing Stengs to shoulder both the creating and the finishing does not widen AZ's space — it narrows it and turns him into the target.

Conversely, if Echteld uses Kwakman as a box-to-box midfielder capable of breaking into the box, keeps Clasie as the tempo-setter, and lets Smit or Stengs alternate as the final destination, the AZ midfield can breathe. Stengs would gain a single second — and in that second, football can turn from bad to brilliant. Every wonderkid starts with a goal the world never saw in time; Kwakman stands exactly on that line, and whether Echteld dares to trust him will shape the entire season.
The problem is that Echteld has shown no sign of tactical flexibility at that level. And Vink, commenting on the situation, said Kwakman deserves to stay in the AZ team after a few matches — but also admitted that when Smit returns, Kwakman may be the one to drop out. For anyone following Dutch football, this is the crucial detail. If the return of a veteran or a recovering player automatically pushes an in-form youngster out of the side, the club is choosing the hierarchy of silence over the voice of the pitch.
AZ's season will be defined by a decision Echteld has not yet made.
Zoom out, and this is not AZ's story alone. The Eredivisie sits between two lines: good enough to produce talent, not rich enough to keep it for long. Stengs returns at 27 — an age at which, by transfer-market logic, a creative player has passed his peak valuation window. Clasie returns like a farewell ritual. Kwakman emerges like an accidental gift. Three different paths, all flowing into one small dressing room in Alkmaar.
History says clubs like AZ do not exist to win titles. They exist to prove that talent can bloom even while the clock ticks. But in Alkmaar right now, the clock is ticking in an uncomfortable way: will Stengs leave in silence, or stay and become the man who fills the void he himself is creating?
I have written before about absence as a protagonist. At AZ this season, that protagonist has no clear shape yet — it is only a gap on the bench, a hesitation in Echteld's eyes, a shot flying into the stands in a bar in Turin where no one loves AZ. Perhaps by the end of the season, we will look back at the Willem II match and understand that it was the moment this club chose its own road.
In an empty stadium, the applause of a million hearts still echoes. But in Alkmaar, there are voids that faith alone cannot fill.
