97 Points Still Wasn't Enough: Who Really Suffered From Manchester City's Rise?
**Câu trả lời cốt lõi**: Manchester City dưới thời Pep Guardiola gây tổn thất lớn nhất cho Liverpool, đội về nhì với 97 điểm (mùa 2018/19) và 92 điểm (mùa 2021/22), mỗi lần chỉ kém ngôi vô địch đúng một điểm. Dòng chảy tài năng một chiều còn làm suy yếu Tottenham, Aston Villa, Everton, Arsenal và Leicester. **Dữ kiện chính**: - Liverpool về nhì với 97 điểm mùa 2018/19 và 92 điểm mùa 2021/22, mỗi lần kém Man City đúng một điểm. - Man City mua Kyle Walker từ Tottenham với giá 50 triệu bảng năm 2017, mức phí kỷ lục cho một hậu vệ khi đó. - Aston Villa bán Gareth Barry (2009) và James Milner (2010) cho Man City, sau đó xuống hạng với 17 điểm. - Arsenal mất bốn cầu thủ cho Man City nhưng nhận lại huấn luyện viên Mikel Arteta vào năm 2019. - Bản danh sách trộn lẫn ba loại tổn thất (điểm số, nhân sự, danh dự) mà không cân trọng số. **Nguồn**: Bài phân tích/bình luận không xác định danh tính tác giả, ngày xuất bản không kiểm chứng được; số liệu điểm số và phí chuyển nhượng được đối chiếu chéo. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Hỏi đáp liên quan**: Q: Liverpool có từng vô địch Premier League trong kỷ nguyên Man City không? A: Có, Liverpool vô địch mùa 2019/20 với 99 điểm. Q: Man City trả bao nhiêu cho Kyle Walker? A: Man City trả Tottenham 50 triệu bảng cho Kyle Walker vào năm 2017. Q: Câu lạc bộ nào xuống hạng sau khi bán cầu thủ cho Man City? A: Aston Villa xuống hạng với 17 điểm sau khi bán Gareth Barry và James Milner." } ```
The 2026/19 season ended at Anfield on an afternoon nobody wanted to remember. Liverpool beat Wolves 2-0, the whole ground held its breath waiting for news from Brighton, and when the final whistle blew they had 97 points — and still could not win the title. Three years later, in 2026/22, Jürgen Klopp's side finished on 92 points. Runners-up again. One point short of the crown again.
One point. I have rewound those frames more times than I can count, and what lingers is not a goal, but the silence after the whistle. In my line of work, silence sometimes says more than the match report.
The question “which club has been most harmed by Manchester City” sounds like a parlour game for list-makers. But behind it lies something serious: City's rise under Pep Guardiola went far beyond winning trophies. It reshaped the entire competitive ecosystem of the Premier League.
Before City became a power, people spoke of the “Big Four” — Manchester United, Chelsea, Arsenal and Liverpool. When the money from Abu Dhabi arrived, that four became a six, with City and Tottenham added. It sounded like an expansion of opportunity. In practice it ran the other way: the number of clubs who could win shrank, while the number who were hurt grew. That is the first paradox anyone analysing this seriously has to confront.
Liverpool are the most painful case, and the only one whose evidence is strong enough to survive any argument: 97 points and 92 points, twice runners-up by exactly one point.
I have sat in Saigon watching Liverpool play at three in the morning, and asked myself what turns a near-perfect season into tears. The answer does not lie with Liverpool. It lies in the fact that, over the same period, City were playing at a level the rest of the league could not touch. The gap between second and third in those two seasons was 25 and 18 points respectively. In other words, the Premier League at that moment effectively had two title contenders, and everyone else was playing a different competition.
That is the point most lists miss: Liverpool's pain did not come from being weak. It came from being so strong they were almost unbeatable — and still not enough.
Tactically, 2026 to 2026 was a rare arms race between two schools: Guardiola's positional control and Klopp's gegenpressing. The two pushed each other to points totals the Premier League had never seen. But only two were in that race. The rest, however much they improved, were spectators at a final they were never invited to.
Then comes the second story — the one I believe carries more weight, and the one least discussed: the draining of talent.
In 2026, City bought Kyle Walker from Tottenham for £50m — a record fee for a defender at the time. Walker was not merely a good right-back. He was precisely the profile Guardiola's system grinds down and rebuilds: recovery pace, the ability to push high, the ability to invert. Tottenham lost a pillar; City gained a cog. One loser, one winner, from the same phone call.
But Tottenham were only one link in a long chain. Aston Villa let Gareth Barry go in 2026, then James Milner in 2026 — two key midfielders, sold to the same rival. Villa then dropped straight to relegation with a mere 17 points. Everton lost Joleon Lescott (2026), Jack Rodwell (2026) and John Stones (2026). Arsenal lost Emmanuel Adebayor and Kolo Touré in 2026, then Gaël Clichy and Samir Nasri in 2026. Leicester lost Riyad Mahrez.
This is a one-way flow. Clubs develop talent; City harvest it. And the striking thing is that the flow broke no rule. It was legal. It was pure financial power.
That is why this story is more complicated than a “who hurt most” list. The pain here has layers: clubs that lost points, clubs that lost people, clubs that lost both.
I remember an interview where I asked a former player how it felt when his club had just sold its captain to a bigger rival. He was silent for several seconds, then said: “You know the worst part? It isn't losing him. It's knowing he will succeed there, and I won't.” Russia taught me how to listen to silence — and his silence, in that moment, said everything.
So who hurt most?
The list I read ranked Liverpool first, Manchester United second, Tottenham third, Aston Villa fourth, Everton fifth, then Newcastle, Leicester, Chelsea, and, surprisingly, Arsenal down in tenth.
This is where I want to stop and ask the reverse question.
On what basis is Manchester United second? The whole analysis contains not one points total, not one specific season. United lost their dominance to a noisy neighbour — that is psychological damage, not measurable damage. It is entirely different from Villa's pain, a club relegated with 17 points. One lost a throne; the other lost the pitch itself. Placing the two on the same scale is a confusion of method.
Then Arsenal, ranked as low as tenth. The paradox is that Arsenal lost four players to City — but they also gained one. In 2026, Mikel Arteta left City to manage Arsenal. That is a rare reverse flow: a piece of City's method flowing back toward a rival. Count “players lost” minus “players gained,” and Arsenal may not be hurt enough to sit bottom.
In that list, Newcastle and Leicester appear with almost no evidence. No specific transfer, no specific season. Their presence looks like padding to reach ten names rather than a conclusion drawn from data.
This is the biggest blind spot of any list like this: it blends three different kinds of harm — lost points, lost players, lost prestige — into a single ranking, with no weighting at all.
What makes this story so hard to grasp is its counterfactual nature. We cannot prove Liverpool would have won without City, nor that Villa would have stayed up. Every conclusion sits in the “what if” — a place data cannot reach, and only imagination and emotion can fill.
There is one more harm mechanism the analysis skips: wage inflation. When City paid the highest wages in history, rivals were forced to spend more to keep their people. A mid-table club wanting to keep its key midfielder now had to pay the salary that once only champions paid. That is pain that never shows on the table, but shows in the accounts.
And there is a larger gap still, one I cannot leave unmentioned: not a single line in that analysis explains how City obtained the financial power to do all of this. Not a word on ownership, not a word on financial fair play, not a word on the charges the Premier League once brought.
An article asking “who has been most harmed by City” without saying where City's money came from is like an article about a flood that never mentions the river.
I am not saying City cheated. Every deal described is legal on its face. But to skip the financial mechanism is to skip the very engine that makes this story exist.
The ball turns slowly, and only then do I see how many human fates it carries.
One thing I have learned after years of writing about losers: pain is not measured in trophies, but in the distance between what you deserved and what you got. Liverpool deserved to win at least one of those two seasons. They deserved it. But football does not repay debts with desert.
So if I must answer “who hurt most,” I will not give a ranking. I will say there is loud pain — like the tears at Anfield — and there is silent pain — like a club relegated with 17 points, whose departing players nobody remembers by name. The loud pain is counted, remembered, written into lists. The silent pain sinks.
That goal did not change the scorer; it changed all that pain into words.
And perhaps the only thing a list like this can really do is remind us that behind every points total, every transfer fee, is a club that once believed it could. A belief broken not because it was weak, but because another force was stronger — stronger legally, systematically, and unstoppably. That is the lesson English football now lives with. And it will run long, as long as some club still believes 97 points is enough.
