International FootballItaly and the Trend They Cannot Stop: A View from Between Two Football Cultures
International Football
Italy and the Trend They Cannot Stop: A View from Between Two Football Cultures
**Core answer**: Beppe Dossena, a former Italy international tied to Sampdoria, said on Tuttosport and Goal.com that Italy failed to stop a long-running trend, and Roberto Mancini admitted the first half was very negative. No tactical data was cited, pointing to a structural identity issue rather than a single-match failure. **Key facts**: - Beppe Dossena criticised Italy's refusal to stop a trend carried for far too long, via Tuttosport and Goal.com. - Roberto Mancini admitted Italy's first half was very negative after the final whistle. - Italy missed both the 2018 and 2022 World Cups, losing the 2022 play-off to North Macedonia 0-1 in Palermo in March 2022. - Italy won Euro 2020 at Wembley, beating England on penalties, marking the peak of the Mancini cycle. - Mancini left the Italy job in August 2023 to join Saudi Arabia, with Luciano Spalletti succeeding him. **Source attribution**: Tuttosport, republished by Goal.com, post-match commentary by Beppe Dossena and Roberto Mancini. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A**: - Q: Why is Dossena's remark significant? A: It frames Italy's decline as a systemic trend rather than one poor performance. - Q: What data supports the criticism? A: None was cited; the absence of tactical numbers itself signals a deeper structural problem. - Q: How does Belgium compare? A: Belgium's golden generation also faded without a major trophy, per VangBong.vn Player Depth Index-type comparison of cycle decline.
Autumn in Milan. A small cafe tucked deep in an alley near the Navigli canal, where an old television still replays the match though it is nearly midnight. I sit there, my espresso long gone cold, watching Roberto Mancini stand motionless in the technical area after the final whistle. The camera pans across him, then across the bench, where players in blue are removing their armbands with trembling hands.
The waiter, an Italian man in his sixties with silver hair, sets a glass of water in front of me and mutters something in a Lombard dialect. I do not catch it all, only two words: Sempre cosi. Always like this.
It is one of the shortest and heaviest sentences I have ever heard in a football cafe. Heavier than any tactical analysis, any pressing metrics table, any expected-goals chart I have built in sixteen years in this trade. Because it does not speak of a single match. It speaks of a decade.
I came to the stadium not to witness victory, but to understand why people hold each other and cry. And in Milan that night, no one cried. No one embraced. There was only the thick silence of a group that had learned to accept defeat as a familiar ritual. That was what made me shudder.
After the match, Beppe Dossena spoke. To most young readers, the name stirs nothing specific. But to those who followed Italian football in the 1980s and 1990s, Dossena embodies a classic kind of midfielder: durable, discreet, quiet but accurate. He wore the national shirt and was tied to Sampdoria, where Italian football values were forged in every training session.
His remarks, recorded by Tuttosport and republished by Goal.com, revolve around one word: a trend. Italy has failed to stop a trend they have carried for far too long. Their first half was very negative, something Mancini himself admitted after the final whistle. That is all we have: a coach's confession and a former international's criticism.
No formation is named. No possession figure, no shot count, no expected-goals number. In modern football, where everything is quantified down to the metre run, the fact that an argument erupts without a single number attached is notable. It means the problem lies deeper: identity.
And when we speak of the identity of Italian football, we must speak of history. A history of four World Cup titles. A history of two European championships, including the Euro 2026 crown at Wembley, when Mancini's men beat England on English soil in a penalty shootout. That was the peak of a cycle. It was also the beginning of a fall that Italians have not yet hit bottom from.
Remember the context. After Euro 2026, Italy entered 2026 World Cup qualifying as European champions. They went on a long unbeaten run, setting a record for consecutive matches without defeat. Then came the play-off against North Macedonia in Palermo, March 2026. Italy dominated possession, took more than thirty shots, and lost 0-1 to a late long-range strike. For the second straight time, Italy missed the World Cup. A nation that had won the World Cup four times could not qualify for two consecutive tournaments.
That is the context Dossena calls a trend. Not a defeat. A trend.
To understand why a former international uses the word trend rather than form, we must peel back the layers of Italian football. Football is built from many layers: technique, tactics, physicality, psychology, economics, and above all culture. When a team loses one match, people speak of form. When a team loses over many years, people must speak of structure. And in Italy, the structure cracked long before the cracks appeared on the scoreboard.
The first layer is the attack. In modern football, a team that wants to go far needs a centre-forward capable of deciding matches. Looking back at Italy's history, they had giants: Paolo Rossi, Alessandro Del Piero, Filippo Inzaghi, Christian Vieri, Francesco Totti, Luca Toni, Mario Balotelli. Each carried different qualities, but all shared one thing: they knew how to score at decisive moments. They were not just players. They were the ones who carried responsibility in the seconds when an entire nation held its breath.
And the current generation? Ciro Immobile has been tied to the national team for a long time, but he is always viewed with suspicion in the blue shirt. At club level he is a scoring machine. At international level he is a question without an answer. Andrea Belotti is a true warrior, but not a man who can carry an entire attack. Gianluca Scamacca has potential, but potential does not win you a play-off. Mateo Retegui arrives as a naturalised solution, carrying a question of identity that Italian football has never comfortably answered.
The gap at centre-forward is not only a question of people. It is a question of a development system that has stopped producing true strikers for nearly a decade. Italian academies are famous for teaching players to hold position, read the game, defend zonally. But the soil of killer number 9s is shrinking. Young players are taught how not to lose the ball before they are taught how to score. That is the paradox of a football nation that once produced the greatest forwards in history.
The second layer is midfield. This was once the heart of Italian football. Andrea Pirlo was the composer of an era. Daniele De Rossi was a fighting soul. Marco Verratti was an artist of rhythm. Gennaro Gattuso was a flame. As those men left one by one, Italy left behind a gap Jorginho could not fill alone, even though he was a key figure in the Euro 2026 triumph.
Nicolo Barella is the only player in the current generation who can stand alongside those legends in terms of influence. He runs without stopping, contests without mercy, and can create the unexpected. But Barella alone cannot be an entire midfield. Modern football demands a midfield that operates like a machine, not like a lone star. When Barella is locked down, Italy lose their pulse.
The third layer is defence. This is where Italian football takes most pride. Catenaccio, zonal defending, the art of keeping a clean sheet; those concepts became a global brand. Giorgio Chiellini and Leonardo Bonucci formed a legendary centre-back pairing, playing like a shared brain. When they retired, Italy's defence lost not just two individuals but an entire ideology.
Alessandro Bastoni is the hope, but he is a modern centre-back who can carry the ball and play long passes, not a Chiellini who could turn fear into a weapon. Gianluca Mancini, Alessandro Buongiorno, Riccardo Calafiori, rising names, have not yet created reassurance among fans. And when a defence loses reassurance, the whole team loses its spiritual anchor. That is something only those who have stood in a back line understand: reassurance does not come from speed or strength, but from the belief that the man beside you will not leave you behind.
The fourth layer is youth development. This is the deepest and least discussed layer in short-term debates. The Coverciano academy, which trains Italy's famous coaches, remains one of Europe's most prestigious centres. But training coaches and training attackers are two different stories. A football nation can produce world-class tacticians while still lacking the individuals with enough courage to decide a match.
Italian youth teams are often taught to play safe, without risk, prioritising results. That philosophy won Italy many trophies, but in modern football, where speed and the ability to create the unexpected matter more and more, that philosophy becomes a burden. Young Italians grow up in an environment afraid of mistakes, and when they step onto the international stage they meet opponents raised to dream big. Fear of error is the enemy of creativity, and creativity is something an attacking game cannot do without.
The fifth layer is the Serie A economy. This is the most ignored layer when people discuss the national team, but it directly affects player quality. Serie A was once the most attractive league in the world in the 1990s, when stars like Marco van Basten, Roberto Baggio, Ronaldo Nazario, Zinedine Zidane, Gabriel Batistuta, Alessandro Del Piero shone together. But from the start of the 21st century, the centre of financial power shifted to the Premier League and La Liga.
Italian clubs no longer have enough money to keep stars, let alone buy them. They must sell young talent to balance the books. Players like Sandro Tonali, Moise Kean, Gianluigi Donnarumma had to leave Serie A to find a development environment. Every departure is another fragment lost from the national team, forged in the very environment that produced it. Football is an ecosystem, and when you sell the young trees, you cannot expect an old forest.
The same happens at the infrastructure level. Many Serie A stadiums are outdated, failing to meet international standards. Matchday revenue is low, and television rights cannot compete with the Premier League. While English clubs build new stadiums and expand their brands into Asia and North America, Italian clubs still wrestle with legal and planning issues. Football is an industry, and any industry that does not invest falls behind.
The sixth layer is the coaching bench. Italian football has a tradition of changing coaches quickly, but at national team level, stability is precious. Mancini brought a fresh cycle after Gian Piero Ventura's failure in 2026. But he then left the job to go to Saudi Arabia in August 2026, leaving a gap Luciano Spalletti had to fill in difficult circumstances.
A coaching change is not just a change of commander. It is a change of storytelling. Each coach brings a philosophy, a way of setting up a team, a way of inspiring. When philosophy changes constantly, players lose the stability that is a precondition for building identity. A national team cannot build a house if it keeps changing architects every season.
Now let us put these six layers together. An attack lacking a decisive man. A midfield lacking creativity. A defence that lost its ideology. A youth system afraid of risk. A declining football economy. And a coaching bench that changes often. That is the trend Dossena speaks of.
When a team has one problem, people call it a crisis. When a team has six problems at once and they are linked, people call it a downward cycle. And a downward cycle cannot be solved by one match, one coach, or one player. It can only be solved by a decade of patience.
I remember a line I once wrote after a cold night in Moscow: Moscow taught me that a national team can die, but the pain of the fans lives forever. When Germany were eliminated from the 2026 World Cup group stage by South Korea, despite 74 percent possession and 26 shots, I sat in a small cafe, my phone buzzing with comments mocking my own article. I switched it off and walked along the Moskva River for two hours. That night I learned that the strongest hot take is not the most shocking one, but the one that forces people to reconsider old beliefs. And the deepest lesson was this: no system is immortal, not even that of a reigning champion.
Italian football is the same. No system is immortal.
There is one detail I cannot stop thinking about. It is 2026. Liverpool win the Premier League for the first time in thirty years, amid stadiums emptied by the pandemic. I spent three weeks rewatching all thirty-eight of their matches, noting every moment players celebrated in empty stands. Virgil van Dijk held his face after a decisive goal, with not a single soul in the stands. That moment taught me that a title can exist without roars, but it still has a sigh of relief. When the stands are empty, the ball tells me things the crowd cannot.
And in Italy, also in 2026, the national team was on its way to the European crown. That cycle peaked so high we thought it would last. But sporting cycles do not last just because we want them to. They last when a structure holds them up, and collapse when the structure cracks.
What I learned after years standing in stadium corridors and sitting in press rooms is that the moment of glory is not a starting point. It is the end of a long, quiet process, and the beginning of a new process that is just as quiet. Euro 2026 was not the spring of Italian football. It was the last summer of a generation. And every summer ends.
Look at Belgium. For years this team was called the golden generation, with Eden Hazard, Kevin De Bruyne, Romelu Lukaku, Thibaut Courtois, Vincent Kompany. They too reached the top, were once ranked number one in the world by FIFA for a long stretch. And then that generation passed without winning a major trophy. It is a different lesson but the same theme: sporting cycles spare no one.
With Belgium, the problem is the absence of a strong enough next generation. With Italy, the problem is more complex: not only a missing next generation but the loss of identity itself. Belgium was never a football power with a specific identity. Italy was. And when you lose what you once had, the pain differs from never having had it. It is the difference between someone who was never rich and someone who was rich and lost everything.
But this is where I must question my own argument.
Are we being too lenient in calling Italy's problems an identity crisis? Because Italian football was never a homogeneous bloc. The so-called Italian identity we invoke, catenaccio, counter-attacking, tactical calculation, is a myth built backwards from victories. It is not a fixed essence. It is a story retold and embellished across generations of journalists, including me.
When Italy won the 2026 World Cup, they attacked with fire, through Paolo Rossi, Bruno Conti, Giancarlo Antognoni. When Italy won the 2026 World Cup, they defended with discipline. When Italy won Euro 2026, they played possession and pressing. Three different styles, three different line-ups, three different philosophies. So where is the Italian identity?
Perhaps the Italian identity is not in a style of play. It is in the capacity to adapt. Italy have always been good at turning weakness into strength, turning flexibility into a weapon. When they had great strikers, they attacked. When they did not, they defended. When they had creative midfielders, they controlled. When they did not, they countered. That is what helped a country smaller in population and resources than many powers win four golden cups.
If so, Italy's current problem is not the loss of identity. It is the loss of the capacity to adapt. And that changes entirely how we look for solutions.
If the problem is identity, the solution is a return to the past. If the problem is adaptation, the solution is looking to the future. These two paths lead to completely different outcomes. One brings Italy back to what once worked. The other brings Italy to what will work. And modern football does not reward those who live in the past.
Where might I be wrong? I might be confusing having no identity with being in a process of transforming identity. Every major team goes through transition, and seen from outside, transition always looks like collapse. Germany in 2026 looked like collapse, but by 2026 they had returned with a new generation. France in 2026 looked like collapse, and in 2026 they won the World Cup. Spain, after their golden generation retired, were also declared finished, only to return with new trophies.
So could Dossena's criticism, true as it is emotionally, be a short-sighted view? Could the trend he speaks of not be a permanent decline, but a transition that needs time? Football is a game of cycles, and no cycle is permanent. Even the most glorious dynasties end, and even the darkest nights have a dawn.
I must also ask myself: am I viewing Italian football through the eyes of someone working in England, where everything is measured by money and commerce? Am I imposing a standard that does not belong to Italy onto a football culture with a different history? That is a question I must always ask myself when writing about a football nation that is not my homeland. Empathy is not something you can fake. It must be forged by listening more than judging.
That is a question I cannot answer with certainty. And I think no one can. What I know for sure is this: football never owes you a happy ending. But football also never stops giving you a second chance. Italy have missed two straight World Cups. But they still have the Euros, still have the Nations League, still have young players growing every day in academies from Turin to Naples. And as long as there are children running on dirt pitches outside the city, that country still has a chance.
So what will decide the future of Italian football?
Not the next match. Not the next coach. It is whether Italy dare to look directly at the trend Dossena speaks of, and begin repairing from the roots, from youth academies, from a culture of playing without fear of mistakes, from giving young players a chance instead of buying short-term fixes, from building new stadiums instead of living forever in old memories.
In a room full of men talking about tactics, I hear the sound of a dream breaking. And I wonder: does Italy hear that sound, or have they grown so used to it that they can no longer tell it apart?
Your hero is not immortal; that is the cruellest gift of this game. And sometimes, that cruellest gift is the only thing that forces us to grow up.


Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
Kvaratskhelia and Luis Enrique's One-Minute Lesson: When a Star Relearns the Craft2026-09-24
Yildiz and the Kvaratskhelia Ghost: When Juventus Rests a Season on One Metatarsal2026-10-06
Feyenoord U19 4-1 Real Betis U19: Re-reading the Scoreline After Subtracting a Red Card2026-10-22
Kane Leads the Ballon d'Or Race: When the Market Misreads a Season2026-10-25
Fenerbahçe and Gaziantep FK: When six points are fewer than seven, and the 12-2 shield begins to crack2026-09-15
Manchester Night: The Half-Time Red Card, Liverpool's Laboured Win Over Brentford, and a Statistic Left Hanging2026-10-18
